Hidden defects: The start of the period for recourse claims is set at the time of compensation, not at the time of discovery of the defect
Published on :
17/07/2025
17
July
Jul
07
2025
Source : www.courdecassation.fr
Cour de cassation, civile, Chambre civile 3, 28 mai 2025, 23-18.781, Publié au bulletin
During renovation work, cladding panels installed on a building were found, after acceptance, to be unstable due to a defect in the treatment of the wooden rafters. The builder and its insurer brought an action against the supplier of the materials and its insurer on the basis of the warranty against hidden defects. The latter objected that the action was time barred.
The Court of Appeal upheld this objection, ruling that the two-year limitation period began to run from the date on which the defect was identified, i.e. in 2017, rendering the action brought in 2020 time barred.
The Court of Cassation overturned this decision. It pointed out that when the builder or its insurer takes action against the supplier to recover sums paid to the client, the limitation period only starts to run from the date of the summons to pay or, failing that, from the date of actual payment of the compensation. The action, brought less than two years after the compensation was paid, was therefore admissible.
History
-
Hidden defects: The start of the period for recourse claims is set at the time of compensation, not at the time of discovery of the defect
Published on : 17/07/2025 17 July Jul 07 2025Publications
Source : www.courdecassation.fr Cour de cassation, civile, Chambre civile 3,...
-
Suspension of prescription: this only benefits the person requesting the expertise appraisal
Published on : 01/07/2025 01 July Jul 07 2025Publications
Source : www.courdecassation.fr Cour de cassation, civile, Chambre civile 3,... -
Construction damage warranty: acceptance of the warranty binds the insurer, even for defects not covered by the ten-year warranty
Published on : 17/06/2025 17 June Jun 06 2025Publications
Source: www.legifrance.gouv.fr The owners of a villa entrusted its constru... -
Vote on the DDADUE law: towards a unified regime for class actions
Published on : 17/06/2025 17 June Jun 06 2025Publications
We are delighted to present the new article ‘Vote on the DDADUE law: towards... -
Photovoltaics: a defect in an integrated connection box entitles the purchaser to compensation under product liability law
Published on : 16/06/2025 16 June Jun 06 2025Publications
Source: www.courdecassation.fr A property owner had hired a company to ins... -
Confirmation of the reversal of case law: the two-year period provided for in Article 1648 of the French Civil Code is a limitation period that can be suspended by an emergency expertise procedure
Published on : 14/03/2025 14 March Mar 03 2025Publications
Source: www.courdecassation.fr A buyer purchased a second-hand vehicle fro...