Construction project blocked: judge may order expert assessment rather than mere hearing
Source: www.courdecassation.fr
The project owners had commissioned a project management company to design a residential house. Despite obtaining two building permits, they terminated the contract, considering that the location was not feasible, and took legal action against the project manager.
Before any legal proceedings, they applied to the judge in summary proceedings for a judicial hearing to preserve the evidence of the facts. On the basis of Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, the Court of Appeal recognised a legitimate reason and, given the technical nature of the dispute (land, plans, budget), ordered not a simple hearing but a legal expert assessment.
The project management company and its insurer appealed, arguing that the judge had modified the claims.
The Court of Cassation dismissed their appeal: since the purpose of the measure remained the same (to preserve or establish evidence), the transition from hearing to expert assessment was a simple matter of assessing the terms and conditions, and did not constitute a modification of the subject matter of the dispute. The appeals were dismissed.
The decision demonstrates the validity of the approach taken by the legislator, who, by decree of 18 July 2025, favoured conventional investigation in order to save time and increase efficiency.
History
-
TORTIOUS LIABILITY – The terms of the engagement letter may be enforced against a third party manager to the contract
Published on : 22/01/2026 22 January Jan 01 2026Actualités
Source: Cass. Com. 17 December 2025, No. 24-20.154 A virtual private... -
Requalification of a professional standard and reminder of the limits on liability arrangements
Published on : 06/01/2026 06 January Jan 01 2026Actualités
Source: www.courdecassation.fr According to Article 1134, paragraph 1, i... -
Construction project blocked: judge may order expert assessment rather than mere hearing
Published on : 22/12/2025 22 December Dec 12 2025Actualités
Source: www.courdecassation.fr The project owners had commissioned a pro...
-
Fire safety in commercial buildings: a new unified framework with Decree No. 2025-1100 of 19 November 2025
Published on : 16/12/2025 16 December Dec 12 2025Actualités
Source: www.legifrance.gouv.fr Decree No. 2025-1100 of 19 November 2025... -
Fire caused by photovoltaic panels: The lessor remains liable for initial defects
Published on : 04/06/2025 04 June Jun 06 2025Actualités
Source: www.courdecassation.fr In commercial leases, the lessor is general... -
Construction: No joint and several liability without shared fault
Published on : 27/05/2025 27 May May 05 2025Actualités
Source: www.legifrance.gouv.fr In construction, several parties may be hel...