Fire and subrogation: compensation is one thing, but you still have to prove the existence and extent of the loss!
A fire destroyed an extension to a building and damaged neighbouring premises. Expert reports revealed several faults that may have exacerbated the damage, notably a lack of waterproofing in an electrical cabinet and a malfunction in an automatic fire-extinguishing system.
After compensating the affected company, the insurers brought a subrogation claim against the companies that had carried out work on the premises and their insurers.
The Rennes Court of Appeal held the interveners liable and assessed the loss of opportunity to prevent the damage from worsening at 25 per cent of the total loss. It ordered them to compensate the victim’s insurers, relying in particular on the subrogation receipts substantiating the sums paid.
The Court of Cassation partially quashed this decision for two reasons:
- Proof of the loss: the subrogation receipts are not sufficient to establish the existence and extent of the damage suffered by the victim. The judges were required to verify the loss for which compensation was actually paid, particularly in the absence of a counter-assessment.
- The assessment of loss of opportunity: this could not be calculated on the basis of the total damage without first determining the proportion of the loss resulting solely from the aggravation of the incident attributable to the established faults.
Key point: an insurer exercising subrogation cannot have more rights than its insured. To obtain compensation, it must establish not only that the subrogation is valid, but also the existence and extent of the loss suffered. As for the loss of the opportunity to prevent a worsening of the condition, this must be assessed on the basis of the damage actually linked to that worsening.
Source: Cass. 2e civ., 17 septembre 2026, n° 24-17.365 et 24-18.000
History
-
ATOUT RISK MANAGER
Published on : 22/10/2026 22 October Oct 10 2026ActualitésIt was with great pleasure that we contributed to issue no. 49 of the magazin...
-
Fire and subrogation: compensation is one thing, but you still have to prove the existence and extent of the loss!
Published on : 15/10/2026 15 October Oct 10 2026ActualitésA fire destroyed an extension to a building and damaged neighbouring premis...
-
Leaders League - Magazine Décideurs : Risk Management & Assurance 2026
Published on : 06/10/2026 06 October Oct 10 2026AwardsWe are very happy to have been rated excellent by the ‘Risk Management & Assu...
- risques-industriels-contentieux-de-la-responsabilite-sinistres-et-contentieux-des-assurances-cabinet-d-avocats-france-risques-industriels-contentieux-de-la-responsabilite-cabinet-d-avocats-2026-1--6ac4b0d4d54d3.jpg
- risques-industriels-contentieux-de-la-responsabilite-regulatory-assurance-reassurance-cabinet-d-avocats-france-risques-industriels-contentieux-de-la-responsabilite-cabinet-d-avocats-2026-6ac4b0d4e4d07.jpg
-
Defective product: The manufacturer remains liable for a safety defect in its machine even if the victim has made unauthorised modifications to it – only the amount of compensation may be reduced
Published on : 02/10/2026 02 October Oct 10 2026ActualitésA farmer had bought a straw baler whose rear door was too narrow to allow h...
-
Subcontracting: the project owner may be required to pay for additional works
Published on : 30/09/2026 30 September Sep 09 2026ActualitésIn a judgement of 3 September 2026, the Court of Cassation reiterated the o...
-
Inexcusable fault on the part of the employer: towards more comprehensive compensation for damages!
Published on : 16/09/2026 16 September Sep 09 2026ActualitésIn a judgement of 3 September 2026, the Court of Cassation strengthened the r...




